| Material | Solid wood (e.g., basswood, birch) | Cardboard or paperboard |
| Durability | Very high – resists bending, tearing, and moisture | Moderate – vulnerable to wear and moisture |
| Piece Thickness | Thick, solid, tactile | Thin, flexible |
| Puzzle Fit | Tight, precise fit | Can vary; some pieces may be loose or wobbly |
| Tactile Experience | Premium, smooth, and satisfying to handle | Lightweight, papery feel |
| Visual Appeal | Often UV-printed or engraved with vivid details | Printed images with matte or gloss finishes |
| Design Variety | Unique cuts, artistic pieces (e.g., animal or whimsy shapes) | Mostly standard interlocking pieces |
| Difficulty Level | Often more challenging due to irregular, artistic cuts | Generally easier with predictable patterns |
| Customization | Highly customizable (e.g., names, photos, laser-cut shapes) | Possible, but limited in form and print quality |
| Eco-Friendliness | Often made from FSC-certified wood, biodegradable materials | Often made from recycled paper |
| Weight | Heavier – more solid feel | Lightweight and easy to transport |
| Portability | Less portable due to weight and sturdier box | Easy to travel with or store |
| Price Range | Higher due to premium material and craftsmanship | More budget-friendly, mass-produced |
| Target Audience | Gift buyers, collectors, adults, enthusiasts | Families, children, casual puzzlers |
| Gifting Appeal | Seen as a luxury or premium gift | Common casual gift |
| Educational Value | Enhances fine motor skills, spatial reasoning, patience | Same benefits, often with more child-friendly themes |
| Collectibility | High – limited editions, artistic or display-worthy | Low to medium – less emphasis on long-term value |
| Packaging | Premium packaging – magnetic, wooden, or drawer-style boxes | Standard cardboard packaging |
| Assembly Sound | Satisfying, solid “click” when placing pieces | Softer, paper-like sounds |
| Longevity | Built to last – can be preserved or passed down | Prone to wear and tear after repeated use |